“Sticks and stones may break my bones,” as the old saying goes. In home design, bones usually remain intact—but stone misused can cause real damage of another kind. Few things disrupt a home’s aesthetic more than the wrong stone choice or an awkward application. Instead of adding timeless beauty, it can make the exterior feel mismatched, unbalanced, and entirely out of place.

You’ve probably seen it: stonework that feels oddly tacked on, too textured, too grey, too...something. On occasion, the material choice is the problem, but in our experience, usually it’s the design that’s off.

At Su Casa, we get a lot of questions both online and in-person about stone: what works, what doesn’t, should I use it, should I not? The list goes on. The truth is, getting stone right is less about what’s trending and more about how it reads on a particular home.

Certain stones naturally align with certain styles. But the trick isn’t just picking the right one, it’s knowing how to use it. Colour, scale, texture, and placement are all crucial decisions (to name a few). What looks great on a sample board can fall flat on a full elevation if the overall layout is off. That’s usually where things start to unravel, and where experience makes the difference.

The cost of using stone makes conversations like this worth having because unlike paint, a mistake with stone isn’t easy to undo.

Bottom line: Stone is permanent. Design regret shouldn't be. What we have to share is what most people wish they’d learned sooner, so read on.

The Art of the Fit: Matching Stone Profiles to Home Styles

Stone profiles are a starting point, not a formula.

Certain stones naturally pair well with certain home styles, not because they follow strict design rules, but because they reflect something fundamental about how those homes are designed and built.

Take fieldstone, for example (pictured below). Its organic shape and softer, collected feel make it a strong candidate for homes that lean rustic or natural and time-worn. We’ve used it on Craftsman, French Country, and Modern Farmhouse projects where the goal was to select materials that looked like they had been collected over time. But it still needs thoughtful execution. If the pieces are too small or the joint pattern too busy, fieldstone can start to feel cluttered. Choose a grout colour too high in contrast and you'll bring a disjointed visual focus to the wrong details.

Ashlar, by contrast, feels more refined and structured. The squared, linear blocks create clean lines and a strong visual rhythm—something that naturally complements homes with symmetry, steep rooflines, and streamlined massing. It’s a pairing that works because both the architecture and the material share a sense of order.

That’s why you’ll often see ashlar used on Tudor or European-inspired homes. Those styles lean into verticality and visual weight—think prominent chimneys, tall gables, and strong base detailing. Ashlar reinforces that language. It gives the stonework a foundational quality, anchoring the home in an orderly, structured way. We've even used ashlar patterns with our modern contemporary homes because the square, linear stonework complements the overall design.

Then there’s ledgestone—narrow, linear, and often read as modern. It’s a natural fit for clean-lined homes with simple gables and horizontal layouts. But it’s more flexible than people assume.

On one of our more popular projects, the Mount Lehman Farmhouse, we used a larger-format ledgestone in a dry stack application to bring a refined rustic feel to the home’s interior (pictured below). The scale and tight jointing gave it a tailored look, while still feeling warm and grounded, proof that execution makes all the difference.

That said, ledgestone does come with limitations. Many manufactured versions have consistent height and length, which can lead to visible pattern repetition, especially across large surfaces. And when the pieces are too small or the layout too busy, it can start to feel chaotic.

The point isn’t to follow style formulas. A great home design uses stone in a way that complements a home’s architecture, proportion, and overall personality. When we work with clients, that’s how we frame it: not “what’s allowed,” but “what makes sense here."

Designer Insight You Need to Know

Here’s something not everyone knows: stone profiles aren’t fixed categories. Terminology like ashlar, ledgestone, and fieldstone comes from traditional masonry, but stone manufacturers often apply these labels loosely. One supplier’s “ashlar” might look nearly identical to another’s “ledge.” You might even see a coursed ashlar blend that reads more like a wide, clean-cut ledgestone.

To the untrained eye, it can all feel like one and the same. But to a designer or mason, the distinctions are real and worth understanding.

That’s where intention comes in. At Su Casa, we often mix stone types within a single project to create a more natural, cultured look. Andy’s own home renovation is a good example (pictured below). He worked with his supplier and mason to create a custom blend using two complementary stone variations from two different collections. Together, they laid out mockups onsite and refined the stone ratios until they felt right, roughly a 70%-30% mix, balancing large fieldstone pieces with smaller-scale ledgestone for a curated, organic result.

This kind of blend is especially useful when working with manufactured stone. Because product often arrives boxed and pre-sorted, pattern repetition is a real risk. Mixing profiles helps disrupt that uniformity, giving the impression of something more authentic and true to form, believable, and timeless.

Design Your Home With Assurance

Stone is one of the most expensive and permanent visual materials you’ll use on a home, so it’s worth getting it right. If you’re looking to build or renovate and don't know how to piece it all together, we'd love to guide you to the right decision.

BOOK YOUR CUSTOM HOME CONSULTATION